Campbell’s replacement was Christy Clark, and she built a campaign around LNG development that promised economic growth, jobs and prosperity.  Her campaign promised a ‘debt-free BC’ and had no problem with negative campaigning.  They attacked Dix from start to finish.  Once again, on election day May 14, 2013, the Liberals repeated their 2005 and 2009 result, winning by four percent.  It was Groundhog Day for the NDP. The Orange Wave many had hoped for, failed to materialize again.  Dix stepped down.